FORENSIC PSYCHOLOGICAL EXAMINATION AS A TOOL OF EVIDENCE IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS RELATED TO FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH COURT DECISIONS

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.32782/forensic.science.2026.4.7

Keywords:

non-compliance with court decisions, psychological examination, interview, loyalty conflict, psychological influence, family disputes, criminal liability, best interests of child

Abstract

The article addresses a relevant, sensitive, and often painful issue for divorced families – the failure to comply with court decisions regarding the determination of a child’s place of residence and the establishment of a visitation schedule. It analyzes the inability of current legislation to ensure the enforcement of court decisions, as well as the inefficiency of civil and enforcement mechanisms in situations where the subject of enforcement is a child rather than property obligations. The authors propose an interdisciplinary approach to solving the problem, which involves combining legal mechanisms, the work of enforcement officers, the involvement of psychologists, and conducting forensic psychological examinations within criminal proceedings under Article 382 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, which criminal liability for systematic non-compliance with court decisions. An algorithm of actions for parents suffering from non-compliance with court decisions is proposed and detailed, along with a list of necessary questions for forensic psychological examination within criminal proceedings. Unlike civil proceedings, such an examination allows for a deeper study of the autonomy of the child’s opinion and the identification of signs of external psychological influence during direct examination (using interviews and psychodiagnostic tools). The article analyzes the main factors that shape a child’s unwillingness to communicate with one of the parents, including involvement in a loyalty conflict, negative interaction experience, indirect influence of the other parent and environment, as well as prolonged parental conflict. Special attention is paid to assessing the child’s declared unwillingness to maintain contact with one of the parents, distinguishing between internal (independently formed) and external (influence of adults or conflict situations, etc.) factors. The conclusions emphasize the need for an interdisciplinary approach where legal sanctions are combined with professional psychological assessment to ensure the best interests of the child.

References

1. Журавльова М. О. Доцільність допиту дитини в суді під час вирішення питання щодо її проживання. Слово національної школи суддів України. 2021. № 1 (34). С. 118–127. URL: http://slovo.nsj.gov.ua/index.php/ua/arkhiv-nomeriv/2021/1-34-2021

2. Журавльова М. О. Автентичність показань дитини під час визначення судом її місця проживання. Проблеми та перспективи розвитку судової експертизи та криміналістики : матеріали Міжнародної науково-практичної конференції, м. Одеса, 16 жовтня 2020 року / відп. ред. А. І. Черемнова. Одеса : Видавничий дім «Гельветика», 2020. С. 170–175.

3. Журавльова М. О. Методика опитування дитини – протокол NICHD (адаптація). Вісник ОНДІСЕ. 2022. № 11. С. 40–48. URL: http://ondise.minjust.gov.ua/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/vipusk-112022.pdf

4. Журавльова М. О. Методика опитування дитини – протокол NICHD (адаптація). Вісник ОНДІСЕ. 2022. № 11. С. 28–39. URL: http://ondise.minjust.gov.ua/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/vipusk-112022.pdf

Published

2026-11-18

How to Cite

Zhuravliova, M., & Rudakova, V. (2026). FORENSIC PSYCHOLOGICAL EXAMINATION AS A TOOL OF EVIDENCE IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS RELATED TO FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH COURT DECISIONS. Forensic Science, (4), 53–59. https://doi.org/10.32782/forensic.science.2026.4.7

Issue

Section

Статті